Football's dangers, illustrated by one young man's brain
By Nadia Kounang, CNN
Updated 11:18 AM ET, Mon January 11, 2016
 |
http://www.cnn.com/2015/09/18/health/high-school-football-injuries/index.html
Head first runs are common in football. |
Michael Keck is proof of the dangers that come with playing football. Michael started playing football at age six and had ten concussions by the time he was 16. He never received treatment for a head injury. In high school, Michael was a star student and decided to go to Missouri State college. In his freshman year while playing football, Micheal was knocked out and suffered another concussion. Unlike previous concussions, Micheal had head and neck pain, insomnia, and amnesia. He was allowed to play within three days of his injury but his symptoms never went away. In the beginning of his sophomore year, Michael stopped playing football. Micheal, once a star student, dropped out of college in his junior year and became depressed and suicidal. Michaels wife said that sometimes he would get so angry he would punch a hole through their wall. Michael believed he had chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) which is not diagnosable in living people. CTE is an Alzheimer's like disease. It affects many pro and amateur football players. CTE is caused by many hits to the head. Michael died of Cardiac arrest in 2013. After he died, it was confirmed that he had CTE. Doctors don't think that his cardiac arrest and CTE were related. CTE is found in 44 of 55 football players but doctors and scientists still know very little about CTE. What we do know is that we should minimalize head contact in young players. Some experts even say that children under the age of 14 shouldn’t be allowed to play football at all.
 |
http://guardianlv.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/hit_4.jpg
Defensive players often lead with their heads when tackling a ball carrier. |
While reading this article, I was very intrigued. I thought it was interesting that even though we know that a lot of football players get CTE, tons of people still want to play. I guess if you love to play, you don’t care about the risks. I also found it interesting how little we know about CTE. We don’t know exactly what causes it or the exact symptoms. All we know is that it’s bad. I was intrigued by the fact that he died of cardiac arrest. I wonder if this has anything to do with CTE. If CTE caused cardiac arrest, it would get a lot more attention. This would cause people to be much more careful. I really liked the article but I also had some critiques. I liked that she showed how big a difference CTE made by saying Michaels GPA. She says, "He had a 3.8 GPA and was offered football scholarships to Alabama, Michigan and Southern California." Later in the article she says, "Keck was also suffering at school, the once star student now had a 1.9 GPA." This made it very clear how much CTE affects its victims. One thing I didn't like is how she explained what CTE is. She says, "The telltale sign of the disease is tangles of the protein tau, which takes over parts of the brain." This confused me a lot. I have no idea what protein tau is. If she had explained protein tau, I would known exactly what CTE was. Even though I had a few problems with the article, I learned a lot and had fun reading it.
I agree that football is dangerous. But I think that if people love playing football and want to risk getting hurt, they should get to play. And it is really fun in my opinion, it's also great to watch!!!
ReplyDeleteI agree with HannahB because when a football player is playing football every Sunday in the season they are all risking a chance of CTE or concussions and hopefully all the football players realize what they signed up for.
ReplyDeleteGreat Job!
P.s. There is a movie about this subject that just came out, it is called Concussion.
you should watch it
By playing football, you are ultimately risking all your health playing. It is very dangerous, but just like any sport, soccer, skiing, etc. However, if people want to accept that risk, they should be able to play. I hope technology for safety eventually catches up, but sports are an amazing way to stay healthy and demonstrate good qualities, such as teamwork and competitiveness. Go Patriots!
ReplyDeleteI agree that football is a dangerous sport and by playing it you are taking the risk of getting serious injuries that being said, If you want to play you should do so and be wary of the risks that it can cause. I feel there is to much attention on the actual game of football and not enough on what it can do to its players.Though sports are a good way to experience healthy competition and the experience of being on a team, they can come at a big price.
ReplyDeleteThis is so true, clearly it proves how much better soccer is than football. The dangers are just too high.
ReplyDeleteThis is very surprising to hear but at the same time it is something that I think people should be at least aware of. I think it's anyones choice but that they should know of the risks. Nice work!
ReplyDeleteWhat I am interested to know is, if we have all this evidence, why wouldn't we ban football for children who are still developing their brains? I am all for banning contact football up to age 14. This could be done with flag football, or illegal tackles like in soccer, not just a free for all. I know that even though my youngest would probably be very good at football, we are sticking with soccer, basketball and lacrosse. His health is more important to me than a dangerous sport which has piles of evidence that causes CTE. Have you ever played football?
ReplyDelete