Showing posts with label Genes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Genes. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 19, 2016

Expert Panel Approves Human Gene Editing


Expert Panel Approves Human Gene Editing

By Tina Hesman Saey- 4:08 pm, December 4, 2015

Student Science


You may have heard of the recents developments in the field of gene editing. Through CRISPR (a piece of RNA which is an information carrying molecule similar to DNA) gene splicing enzyme called Cas9 is guided to any string of DNA which it cuts and and changes. This is effectually a copy, cut and paste action in the DNA of virtually any living organism. This technique has the potential to eliminate faulty genes that cause such diseases as hemophilia- a disease where a person’s blood is in able to clot and even the smallest cut can be life threatening.
Gene editing even has the potential to cure cancer, as in the case of a one year old girl named Layla, whose Leukemia was cured do in part to gene editing. The world has never seen anything like this before, and good news, on December 3rd, 2015, a panel of experts convened in Washington D.C. and decided that research on gene editing will be allowed to proceed.
This is huge, the whole world will feel the effects of this. So many diseases could be cured. And because of that who knows what other chain reactions will occur. Imagine what Africa would be like right now if the Ebola outbreak had never occurred. The world will never be the same.
I’m very excited by this news, for a couple of reasons. First of all, for the sake of pure scientific advancement, this is huge. So many things are already possible because of gene editing, and we haven’t even discovered all the possibilities. Curing diseases isn’t all gene editing can do anything. Practically anything relating to the body or the makeup of an organism could be change, as long as there are genes involved. This is straight out of a sci-fi movie.
Besides that, I was already previously interested in genes and how they effect your body. I already knew of the existence of CRISPR and I’m very excited to see where this new study will go.
But as there always is, there is still another issue. Researches are not allowed to edit human embryos that will be placed into mothers to be. Here’s a quote from the article-

‘“The gene-editing committee said that moral, ethical and safety concerns would make it ‘irresponsible’ to proceed with human studies in germ line cells. Changing these cells would transmit the edits on to future generations.”

Germ line cells, if edited will be passed down to the future generation. And it was decided that meddling with and placing artificial genes into children would be morally incorrect if passed down unto future generations. I’m still not sure myself whether those types of traits should be edited– on the one hand I can see how that might end being synonymous with playing god, but on the other I would like to see how such an experiment would proceed. This could also be beneficial for future generations. Let’s say that the gene for cancer immunity was passed on to future generations, we could eventually have a cancer free world.
This article has really torn me, I’m not sure where I stand on this issue. If i had to choose one side it would have to be the pro-germline editing side. I think the science in this is just too important to pass up due to some moral issues. But it’s not up to me so I guess I’ll just have to wait and see where this goes. But, in the mean time I’ll be studying cells in our upcoming unit which just so happens to directly connect to my article (*wink* *wink*, there’s that connection the rubric asked for). So, where do YOU stand on the issue? Do you think the editing of germline cells is ethical. Do you want designer babies?

Beagles edited by researchers in China. Click here to see the beagle article


Click here to read the article by Tina Hesman Saey

Expert panel approves human gene editing

Tina Hesman Saey

DECEMBER 4, 2015


New Gene Editing Tool

If you’ve ever wondered if scientists could prevent humans from getting terrible diseases, then this is the article to read! There’s a thing called scissors, which is a chemical that changes or, edits DNA in a living organism. Scissors help damaged DNA, and makes the DNA stronger. This will affect the person that is getting gene editing done, if they have a serious disease. For example, In November 5, 2015 a one year old baby named Layla who had leukemia was given gene editing which helped push the child into remission. The performance of gene editing occurred in Great Ormond Street Hospital in London, England. Scientists are saying that gene editing can only be used for serious diseases, like what one year old Layla had. If gene editing is used in an appropriate way, then it can only be used for helping and saving children with terrible diseases.


I chose this article because I’ve heard a tiny bit of gene editing and, wanted to know more about it, and thought it was an interesting discovery. This is connected to what I’m soon going to be learning in class, we are learning about cells and DNA. This article is talking about human DNA, which is near the area of human biology. Before learning about this topic, I knew that gene editing was a thing that could happen. Another thing, I knew before reading the article is that people have been talking about changing your DNA a bit. I think this news is important so we know if a young child has a diseases, scientists could change it and edit the DNA. This is useful so people with leukemia or something else. So the DNA part that had leukemia was cut and got rid of. This will affect people that have a disease. This discovery is making a difference by saving people’s life. I have been very interested into DNA after I learned about Charles Darwin’s Natural Selection Theory. This discovery was needed so we could help save people that have terrible diseases. I don’t think that this could affect me, but I could see why I could affect other people.

I’m very happy if scientists allowed scissors to happen and help patients if they were diagnosed with some terrible disease. It really gets me thinking, if we only used DNA editing for diseases then it would be great! But if we were producing designer babies what good would that do? Scientists are saying that it would be unethical to create designer babies. Gene editing can only be used for people with diseases, which I agree with. David Baltimore (a biologist, that won a Noble Prize in 1975) said ‘’ As long as cells are not implanted into woman to create a baby, it is not germ line editing.’’ He’s saying that scissors can’t be used when the woman is pregnant, it has to happen after the child is born.



The procedure of gene editing with scissors